RICHARD WILLIAM TIMM was born in Michigan City,
Indiana, USA, on March 2, 1923 to parents of German descent. His father, Joseph, was
paymaster at the Pullman Company, the manufacturer of railway cars; his mother, Josephine
Otten, was a housewife. Both were devout Roman Catholics, and TIMM recalls that he and his
three siblingsan older brother and two younger sisters"were raised with a
strong sense of duty, including fidelity to our religion and its practices." TIMM
served the local church as an altar boy, and attended St. Mary's Grade School and then St.
Mary's High School, where he was taught by Holy Cross Sisters.
His first awareness of missionaries came when he was just four. Having tagged along to
St. Mary's with his brother he met Sister Cleophaswho gave him a silver-framed
picture of St. Therese, patroness of the missions. Sister Cleophas later became his first
grade teacher and inspired his love and devotion.
For TIMM the missionary vocationrather than parishalways matched his
personal inclinations. From earliest years he loved adventure; indeed his first memory is
of being lost in the city at age three. In subsequent years he remembers his father
gathering his sons into a great armchair and reading them stirring yarns of physical
heroism and moral valor in exotic places. Among such tales were Winnetou the Apache
Chief by Karl May, in which a white man became blood brother to an American Indian.
Although in childhood games the Indians "were the bad guys," from stories such
as these TIMM imbibed an "impression of the brotherhood between all peoples."
TIMM took an early pleasure in nature, as well, going off for long solitary walks in
nearby woods and fields and cultivating a small patch of wild flowers in his backyard.
This love of nature later led him into biological research.
Studying hard, he also led a vigorous life outside the classroom, playing football and
basketball at St. Mary's High and, although shy, competing successfully in debates and in
state-wide Latin competitions. During summer vacations he worked at various jobs, one
summer soliciting door-to-door for a furnace cleaning company, another selling ice cream
and milk shakes at a tourist stand on the lake front of his hometown.
TIMM felt very much in the shadow of his older brother, who preceded him in school by a
year and a half and was brilliantly successful in all his endeavorsa loquacious,
winning salesman, a natural leader, and a football and basketball hero. Nevertheless he
learned to be successful in his own right.
In his final high school year TIMM clarified his religious ambitions. He considered the
Jesuits, and indeed won a four-year scholarship to a Jesuit university, but was drawn to
the "obvious holiness and intellectual depth" of Father William Robinson, a Holy
Cross priest who gave the Lenten series in his parish. After meeting Robinson TIMM visited
Moreau (Holy Cross) Seminary at Notre Dame University where he was assured he could study
for a Bachelor of Science in biology. Therefore on September 9, 1940 TIMM entered Moreau
to take the path to the priesthood, a path from which he never wavered.
To his disappointment, however, a new Superior of the order had been appointed, who
required the seminarians to study for the degree of Bachelor of Arts. TIMM did so but
squeezed into his academic program as much science as he could, including zoology, organic
chemistry and histology (a branch of anatomy that deals with the minute structure of plant
and animal tissue). In these courses he was often the only seminarian and very
conspicuous, with his six feet two inches of height covered by a black habit and cape. He
graduated magna cum laude in 1945 with a B.A. in Philosophy.
In April that year his brother was killed in World War II. The day he heard the news
TIMM promised himself to work twice as hard "so my life could make up for the
shortness of his."
In preparation for ordination TIMM now embarked upon four years of theological studies
at Holy Cross College in Washington, D.C. The attitudes at the college struck him as both
anti-intellectual and antiscientific: the church had not yet made its peace with
evolution, and the study of science generally was still viewed as "dangerous. "
The young scholar might have rebelled against theology altogether had he not read the
works of French philosophers and theologians Etienne Gilson, Jacques Maritain and others
who were the spiritual forerunners of the Second Vatican Council. I heir approach to
theology comported better with his own evolving faith.
After his ordination on June 8, 1949 Holy Cross assigned TIMM the responsibility of
establishing a department of science at St. Gregory's, its newly opened college in Dhaka,
East Pakistan. In order to do so he had first to acquire a Masters Degree. Enrolling at
Catholic University of America (also in Washington), he plunged into the study of biology
with such fervor that in two years he had completed not only the requirements for his
masters, but the course work for a Ph.D. The order permitted him a year to write his
doctoral dissertation on nematodes ("elongated cylindrical worms parasitic in animals
or plants, or freeliving in soil or water," commonly called roundworms). His paper,
"The Marine Nematodes of Chesapeake Bay," was published by the Marine Biological
Laboratory at Solomons Island, Maryland.
Having completed his formal education the young priest traveled to Dhaka in 1952,
traveling via France to visit the mother house of the Holy Cross Fathers, and Rome where
he and his companions had an audience with Pope Pius XII. He arrived in Dhaka, East Bengal
(Pakistan) in late October.
As a naturalist TIMM delighted in the exotic birds and blossoms he found in Bengal, but
his new home took adjusting to. In the beginning he suffered from dysentery and worms. He
found traffic so maddening that he gave up driving a car, and yet found wing hand-pulled
rickshaws repugnant. Consequently, he began getting around the crowded city lanes on a
bicycle; today he uses a motorcycle.
For the next two decades TIMMs life would center around Notre Dame College (as
St. Gregory's was renamed) and science, establishing the science curriculum for the
college, teaching many of the course, and devising appropriate teaching material. The
latter necessitated writing a biology textbook based on the local flora and fauna.
TIMM also taught at Dhaka Medical College under a Fulbright Lectureship in Parasitology
(1953-54), and continued his research on jute and rice nematode parasites at the
Agricultural Research Institute, Tejgaon and under a grant from the Ministry of Food and
Agriculture, Pakistan (1954-70). At the same time he served as external examiner in
zoology for the University of Dhaka, and in parasitology for the Bangladesh Agricultural
University.
Throughout the 1961 his religious responsibilities were also heavy.
He served as Religious Superior of Notre Dame's Holy Cross Fathers, Secretary of their
Vicarate Council and Director of Seminarians.
On his first scientific trip in Bengal (1956 to Cox's Bazaar, near the Burmese border)
TIMM collected specimens of nematodes with pathbreaking results. Of the 89 species of
marine nematodes he collected, 56 were new to science! His findings were published as the
first issue of the Proceedings of the Pakistan Academy of Sciences (1961).
In 1963 TIMM joined a team of Bengali, American and European scientists to investigate
the Sunderbansa crocodile and tiger infested mangrove swamp in the delta of the
Ganges, Brahmaputra and Meghna riverswhere he gathered materials for four scientific
papers in which he described 2 new genera and 14 new species of nematodes.
Some of TIMM's research had important ramifications for Bengali agriculture. At the
invitation of the Central Jute Research Institute (1960) he studied the influence of
nematode parasites on a wilting disease affecting jute, East Pakistan's most important
export crop. He discovered that certain nematodes stimulated root growth and enhanced
yields if a common soil fungus (Rhizoctonia solani) was suppressed; other research
done in collaboration with a plant pathologist at the Jute Institute showed that a common
imported nematicide failed to produce higher yields commensurate with its cost. For the
Food and Agriculture Council of Pakistan TIMM conducted a survey in 1963 of parasitic and
soil nematodes affecting other local plants, and in the same year he won a SEATO
(Southeast Asia Treaty Organization) Postdoctoral Research Fellowship to make an extensive
study in Thailand and the Philippines of parasitic nematodes affecting commercial plants
such as rice, jute, papaya, pineapple, wheat and coffee. He toured these countries for two
months each and collated his data at the University of California at Davis when he was
there on home leave; his findings were published as a book by SEATO in 1965.
TIMM attributes his prodigious output during the 1950s and 1960s (over 70 scientific
papers) to the fact that he was the only nematologist in Bangladesh. His fellow priests
barely understood what he was doing but they respected his work and helped him by assuming
his religious and educational responsibilities when the demands on his time were too
great, or when he was away.
In 1968 TIMM left East Pakistan to spend two years' leave in the United States. With
the title of Visiting Professor he joined the faculty at Davis, California where he taught
nematology and zoology and pursued his research. His years there coincided with great
societal upheavals in the U.S. concerning the Vietnam War, civil rights, black power, and
Cesar Chavez's efforts to organize the farm laborers in California. These issues gripped
both the campus and the parish of St. James, where he officiated on weekends. Harkening to
the liberal teachings of the Second Vatican Council, TIMM took a stand. He helped organize
an ecumenical memorial service for Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., whose stand for
"oppressed people's God given rights and human dignity" TIMM considered,
"an act of radical Christianity." As part of a group called Clergy and Laity
Concerned about Vietnam he opposed American participation in the war; some Saturdays he
joined student volunteers who were aiding a self-help housing project for low-income
Mexican-American farmers. In his sermons he addressed the issues of social Justice and the
war, a fact not always appreciated by his more conservative parishioners, and he spoke on
behalf of the Holy Cross missions in East Pakistan. At the same time TIMM managed to
complete a major work, Revision of the Nematode Order Desmoscolecida, published by
the University of California Press (1970).
During his second year at Davis TIMM spent 10 weeks with a National Science Foundation
team at McMurdo Naval Base in Antarctica. The first nematologist to be part of Operation
Deep Freeze, he collected soil, freshwater and marine nematode specimens, including three
new genera and nine new species. His research led eventually to three publications. While
residing at the base TIMM also served as Catholic chaplain, and grew a beard which he
decided to keep on his return to California, "mainly to show people in the parish who
despised 'hippies' that I was no different from the person I had been without a beard.
Returning to Bengal in October 1970, TIMM participated in the International Symposium
of Nematology in Italy enroute. On his arrival in Dhaka he learned that he had been
appointed college principal "effective immediately." But a natural catastrophe
intervened which was to change the direction of his life.
With his colleagues at the college TIMM listened to the radio on the night of November
12, 1970 as storm warnings were issued. When the signal reached 6 the announcer abandoned
numbers altogether and began warning urgently of "grave danger." The winds along
the coast that night reached 120 miles per hour, and a tidal bore 20 feet high swept over
the coastal villages, drowning some 250,000 people. The government was not prepared to
respond; it was 17 days before relief units of the Pakistan army were mobilized. In the
meantime individuals and organizations did what they could. With volunteers from Notre
Dame, organized a relief team. When the government declined their assistance they joined
HELP (Heartland Emergency Lifesaving Project) which had just been set up by Fazle Hasan
Abed (1980 Magsaysay Awardee for Communiq Leadership), and Viquar Chowdhury and others to
assist the cyclone victims. TIMM and his colleagues, along with American doctors and their
wives from the SEATO Cholera Research Laboratory, rushed aid to Manpura Island, a
low-lying region in one of the most heavily damaged areas. More than half Manpura's
population of 80,000 had perishedin particular its children, women and elderly; the
waters and coast were dotted with their bloated bodies and the bodies of drowned animals.
TIMM and his group made their headquarters in a local primary school whose battered brick
building could still be used as a makeshift storehouse, but they slept in tents outside.
SEATO doctors handled problems of health and the distribution of relief goods, and the
Notre Dame team conducted a survey to ascertain who had survived and what assets they
still possessed, e.g. cows, ducks, tools, building materials. The team set up 1,000 tents
for the homeless survivors, and after the doctors left TIMM himself became an acting
paramedic.
TIMM found much to admire in the island people's stoic yet enterprising response to
disaster men soon constructed dwellings from the flood's debris, and journeyed to the
mainland to seek new wives. On the other hand, despite HELP's efforts to distribute relief
goods equally, village leaders often took the lion's share: one village headman
commandeered 17 blankets for his immediate family.
By January the Manpura relief volunteers felt they could return to Dhaka, and TIMM took
up his post as principal at Notre Dame. Shortly thereafter HELP asked him to become Field
Coordinator for the rehabilitation (in contrast to relief) program of Manpura Island.
Leaving his college chores in the hands of a willing colleague, TIMM went happily,
counting on the fact that his colleagues considered an absent superior a good one.
On the island again TIMM was actively involved in assisting the government in a crash
program to build new housing before the rainy season, and in acquiring cattle and water
buffalo to replace those drowned. HELP decided to follow the directive of government that
all rehabilitation projects be carried out through cooperatives, an interesting but highly
idealistic experiment at the time, but one which TIMM was later to assess as successful.
HELP workers held meetings to introduce the idea Since rehabilitation goods from
non-government organizations (NGOs) were to flow through cooperatives, virtually everyone
joined. Eventually 75 such groups were formedamong fishermen to build new boats,
among farmers to rebuild villages and receive needed seeds, tools and animals.
To assure that cattle were distributed fairly, HELP required each cooperative to hold a
lottery and submit members' names in the order in which they were drawn. The results were
astonishing in one predominantly Muslim village, all the Hindus came last, in another,
members of the leading family held the first four places. Yet villagers swore that the
lottery had been carried out fairly. This was TIMMs first introduction to the power
structure of the village; in egregious cases he intervened and banned the offenders.
Political tensions between East and West Pakistan, which had been building for some
time, were exacerbated by the late response of the government in West Pakistan to the
cyclone disaster. Along with the political tensions came heightened ethnic and religious
hostilitiesbetween Bengali and non-Bengali Muslims, and between Bengali Muslims
(many of whom were originally lower caste Hindu converts) and Hindus (the minority, but
often the landed class).
In March 1971, on a trip to Chittagong to buy cattle, TIMM heard news of the slaughter
in Dhaka of "120,000 Bengalis" by Pakistan soldiers. Although the actual number
later proved to be "several hundred," TIMM was a near victim of the patriotic
hysteria that followed. Tanned, bearded and wearing surplus US army pants, he was mistaken
for a West Pakistani soldier and escaped danger only by addressing the angry crowd in
Bengali, telling them of his relief efforts on Manpura.
During the succeeding nine months the Mukti Bahini (Bengali freedom fighters), armed
and trained by India, waged guerrilla war against the Pakistani army and those loyal to
the regime. TIMM helped provide accurate information to the outside world about events and
conditions in his area of East Pakistan. Letters by him and others in HELP were wed to
sway the U.S. Senate Armed Forces Committee to call for a temporary halt of U.S. military
aid to Pakistan, and to counteract Pakistan's propaganda picture of life as normal in
Bengal.
The treatment of Hindus, TIMM found, was one of the most depressing features of the
hostilities. After the initial weeks, when the army attacked villages indiscriminately,
the full force of the army's wrath fell on Hindus or kafirs (non-believers). And
when Bengali Muslims saw they were safe, many joined in the persecution of kafirs.
On Manpura Hindus (who comprised 30 percent of the population) were terrorized by the army
and systematically excluded from all government relief and rehabilitation. TIMM boldly
attempted to stop such actions by claiming authority from high government officials he
either knew or pretended to know. This frequently succeeded.
At the same time he forged ahead with the rehabilitation program, distributing 2,000
pairs of cattle, launching an agricultural loan program, and overseeing the completion of
thousands of new homes. In July he returned to Dhaka, "relieved in mind and
body," particularly the latter: he was 40 pounds lighter than he had been eight
months before.
When he left Manpura TIMM pondered the problems of disaster relief and rehabilitation.
What people needed most, he concluded, was to be partially fed and clothed, and aided in
their efforts to house themselves and get a new crop in the ground. The key was to furnish
them with money as quickly as possible so they could purchase food and other
materials within the country (this would have the added benefit of stimulating the local
economy) and get the next rice crop into the ground. Baby foods, milk powder, medicines
and other items sent by well-meaning donors from abroad were often inappropriate and tied
up transport, unloading and storage facilities. A catastrophe, he also realized, is not
the time to introduce unfamiliar foods: the Bengal famine of 1945 had shown that even when
standing the people did not eat the plentiful but unfamiliar frogs and river dolphin.
The insistence on rehabilitation through cooperatives "was a good
experience," TIMM concluded, but building cluster villages was a big mistake. The
erection of three large cyclone shelters was useful, but the numerous smaller
shelterswith a ground floor for ordinary purposes, and a second floor and roof for
cyclone protection were more suitable and better adapted to the scattered living patterns
of the islanders.
After he returned to his responsibilities at Notre Dame in August TIMM continued
gathering information on conditions in the countryside. About this time the two founders
of HELP, Abed and Chowdhury, started a new organization in London to lobby for
independence which they named Help Bangladesh. Afraid the government would crack down on
HELP in Dhaka, the Governing-Body decided to separate itself from the London operation and
elected TIMM chairman. This gave TIMM the opportunity to continue working with NGOs
and ensuring that foreign aid reached those for whom it was intended. With his previous
experience, and his knowledge of the country and the language, he was more valuable than
most of the hundreds of foreigners who were brought in after the war by various relief
agencies. Catholic Relief Services (CRS) agreed, and appointed him its Roving National
Field Representative, responsible for helping set up rehabilitation projects in the most
war-torn areas. The position allowed TIMM to return to Manpura as needed, where the
protection of Hindus was his main concern.
Hostilities escalated toward year's end and on more than one occasion TIMM was in
potential danger; but in each case former students appeared to vouch for him. Foreign
NGOs, including CRS, began moving their expatriate staffs out of East Pakistan and
suspending operations. Undaunted, TIMMwho had committed himself to Bengal from the
day he arrivedswitched his activities to the Christian Organization for Relief and
Rehabilitation (CORR), established in January 1971, which took up the slack left by other
relief organizations. By November TIMM was supervising 55 projects and was still moving
food and other materials to needy areas. The War of Liberation of Bangladesh reached its
climax with the entry of the Indian army into the fray on December 7, 197; Pakistan's
forces surrendered on December 16. Independence for Bangladesh brought 10,000,000 refugees
streaming back from India.
As Relief Coordinator for CORR; TIMM now set out to help convert relief projects into a
nationwide reconstruction program. CORR drew up a US$30 million budget and received an
immediate pledge for US$12 million from the Vatican relief committee. On December 28 TIMM
and CORR Director Fr. Benjamin Labbé showed their skeletal plans to Bangladesh's new
Secretary of Relief and Rehabilitation. By the first of the year they were ready to start
work. Their immediate goal was to rehabilitate more than 200,000 families, assist them in
rebuilding their plundered homes and in restoring their means of livelihood. CORR
distributed oxen, ploughs and seed to farmers; sewing machines to garment makers; and
carpenter, blacksmith and goldsmith tools to craftsmen.
TIMM worked seven days a week, traversing the country in CORR's 7-passenger airplane,
designed for short take-off and landings, and in fiberglass speedboats furnished by CORSO,
New Zealand. He and his CORR teammates developed a reputation for mobilizing relief
quickly, with the least possible overhead. Because of their acumen new funds flooded in,
including an unsolicited US$1.5 million from the Dutch Committee for Aid to Refugees. In
May 1972, at the peak of its reconstruction efforts, CORR was disbursing more than US$1
million a week!
As TIMM's reputation grew, so did the demand for his counsel, and his friend, Dr.Jon
Rohde, a colleague in HELP who had returned home, wrote, "We have directed virtually
every aid-giving group to you, including the UN!"
The dramatic events of 1971 and 1972 had redirected TIMMs own life, his
interests, concerns and his interpretation of missionary work. He had abandoned
conventional teaching and life as a research scientist, and with them his cloistered
distance from the people. He had learned to speak Bengali fluently, and had rejected his
previous aloofness to politics. As he later wrote, "My attitude changed rapidly. . .
when it became apparent that politics was resulting in genocide . . . . and after the war
I learned that even such non-political activities as relief, rehabilitation and
development are in actuality highly political and that without some kind of political
involvement working for the poor is only an exercise in charity."
In assessing the consequences of CORR's efficient relief efforts TIMM recognized there
was a negative side to it the inculcation of an attitude of dependency among relief
recipients. The key to breaking the cycle of dependency, TIMM concluded, was breaking the
cycle of neediness itself. This meant economic development. From 1973 on, therefore, CORR
redirected its efforts to this more comprehensive goal.
CORR's philosophy of development was non-technocratic. It emphasized understanding
people and their needs in the context of their culture and socio-economic structure. It
encouraged development based on shared goals, and was pragmatic, undertaking pilot
projects, working through small groups, andin order to help people help themselves
stressing practical training. Like TIMM, other leaders of CORR had been in the country for
many years or were locals; they knew the people and their needs and consequently were able
to begin programs of help, often before other agencies knew needs existed.
For example, the war had created many widows, among them a large proportion of Hindus
who are not permitted to remarry. One of CORR's most successful projects addressed their
desperate need for livelihood.
This was the Jute Works, a cooperative handicraft for export project, that capitalized
on the cheap raw material readily available in the country, jute, the golden fiber of
Bangladesh." Building upon an already existing women's cooperative and training
center founded by Holy Cross Sister Olivia Salazar, the Jute Works promoted development of
cooperatives of village handicraft producers countrywide. Although the work was done by
women in their homes, design, quality and the marketing process were firmly controlled by
CORR in Dhaka. Today over 30,000 women make Jute Works items whose annual export worth
exceeds US$2 million.
The Jute Works has not been an unqualified success, however. The income provided
individual women is usually a supplementary rather than a full income, and efforts to
diversify into leather crafting and ceramics failed. Moreover, the Jute Works has had on
occasion to confront the wrenching problem of dishonesty in its leadership.
Development in Bangladesh, TIMM quickly discovered, requires like-minded NGOs and
international donors to work cooperatively. When they do not, mistakes are repeated, and
even well conceived projects are wastefully duplicated. To coordinate the work of the many
NGOs, TIMM in 1974, led in the creation of the Association of Voluntary Agencies in
Bangladesh (AVAB) and was elected first Chairman of its Executive Committee. AVAB became
ADAB in 1978 (Agricultural Development Agencies in Bangladesh), whose name was changed in
1983 to Association of Development Agencies in Bangladesh. TIMM served ADAB as director
for nine months in 1978, and later as a consultant when ADAB took on the additional task
of representing voluntary agencies vis-a-vis the government.
In October 1973 HELP was incorporated into CORR, of which TIMM became Executive
Director the following year, a position he accepted on the condition that a Bangladeshi
director be found as soon as possible. The search took two and a half years. During this
time TIMM changed the name of CORR to Caritas Bangladeshto remove the words
"Christian" and "Rehabilitation" and to express solidarity with
similarly named Catholic charities elsewhere.
By this time the organization had 13 senior staff members, three of whom were Holy
Cross fathers, and was receiving funding from several dozen donors around the world. The
largest amount came from Catholic philanthropies in Holland and Germany (CEBEMO and
Misereor). TIMM oversaw a budget of approximately US$6.5 million. During the next few
years Caritas Bangladesh maintained the ongoing Jute Works, a village irrigation project
involving some 170 irrigation cooperatives, and made strenuous efforts to encourage
cooperatives in commercial fishing. At the same time it: 1) constructed 21 rural roads and
70 bridges; 2) excavated 8 year-round canals; 3) installed 28 ring wells; 4) dug or
repaired 48 water tanks for use as fish ponds and for bathing, laundry and cooking water;
5) built 417 low cost houses for later cyclone victims; 6) cared for 700 destitute refugee
families; 7) rushed rice, biscuits, salt, kerosene, oil and rice seedlings to flood
victims in Chittagong; 8) funded 6 orphanages and 4 eye hospitals; 9) set up a feeding
camp for vagrants; 10) established an experimental farm to study suitable crops for dry
season farming; and 11) trained hundreds of rural health workers to immunize villagers
against smallpox, check for tuberculosis, and run "birthing and under five"
clinics.
As a hands-on director, TIMM became uniquely familiar with the countryside and its
stubborn resistance to social and behavioral change. On every trip, he wrote, "I
would encounter at least one instance of corruption or flagrant injustice to the poor and
the powerless." In spite of independence and the democratically elected government of
Sheik Mujibur Rahman, he found the government was doing nothing to improve the quality of
service or control corruption. Mujibur was proving as blinded by power as the Government
of Pakistan that he replaced. In consequence the mores of the people did not change and
Caritas continued to face problems of corruption at all levels.
TIMM stepped down as director of Caritas Bangladesh in December 1976 to become its
Roving Consultant. For his services Pope Paul VI awarded him the Pro Ecclesia et
Pontifice medal.
TIMMs and Caritas' growing awareness of the intransigence of the rural power
structure coincided with a burgeoning awareness of social inequalities by the Catholic
Church itself. The Bishops' Institute of Social Action, meeting in Malaysia in 1975,
indicated as much when it voted to examine the "social dimension of the Gospel in the
light of Asia today. "
In 1974 the Catholic Bishops Conference of Bangladesh mandated the Bangladesh Justice
and Peace Commission (of which TIMM was the organizer) to identify injustices, explain
their causes, and suggest practical Christian solutions for the church to act upon. When
circumstances warranted, prudent protests could then be registered with the authorities.
Using TIMM's own studies, the Justice and Peace Commission documented Bengali
discrimination against tribal minorities and investigated national corruption and
dishonesty. A paper written for the commission by TIMM in 1978 declared that the disparity
between the rich and poor in Bangladesh was "one of the most sinful situations of our
time." Finding this declaration a bit imprudent, the Bishops' Conference declined to
be identified with it, and to TIMMs disappointment, the paper had little local
impact.
In project evaluations for NGOs and government donors such as U.S. AID TIMM became
increasingly critical of development projects favoring rural elites. To illustrate the
problem anecdotally, he mentioned one village in which the largest landowner was also
manager of the village's two aid-funded irrigation projects and chairman of the village
development committee; perhaps as a consequence of the latter, a UNICEF fish pond also
graced his property, the profits therefrom accruing to him.
Because cases like this were all too common, TIMM began steering Caritas Bangladesh to
projects that fostered the needs of homogeneous groups of rural poor: landless
laborers, marginal farmers, tea plantation workers and women. Women he considered
"the most deprived general class of the society." He also began promoting
awareness-building to help the powerless learn to understand the nature and causes of
their lack of power and show them how to take united action to redress the situation. He
advocated "active non-violence," concluding hopefully: "When enough people
are engaged with intelligence and dedication in the movement for the common people's
rights then there will be a 'truth force' (salryagraha) which no one can
stop."
To plumb these problems more deeply, TIMM turned once more to research. His own study
of the socio-economic impediments to development, Power Relations in Rural Development:
The Case of Bangladesh, was published in 1983. In this paper he showed that elite-led
development for modernizing agriculturewith large landowners controlling the
distribution of aid-subsidized irrigation, credit, fertilizers and
pesticidesactually increased the number of landless peasants and marginal farmers.
In three studies made between 1982 and 1984 he documented the harsh, insecure lives of
Bangladesh's women workers. In another he examined the government's foreign-aid-funded
population program which encouraged sterilization among poor women by offering them
material incentives. He concluded that the program was depriving poor women of their
"right not to be forced into life-limiting situations" (although he did not
prove that material inducements were a deciding factor), and that the program was careless
in providing post-operative medical services.
TIMM also organized a series of seminars for women workers in the tea, garment and
cigarette industries, nurses, domestics and farm laborers, in which he encouraged the
women to learn from each other's
fences. Many participants expressed the desire to continue meeting, and the result was
the formation, in 1986, of the Coordinating Council for Human Rights in Bangladesh, with
TIMM as coordinator.
His next project was a study on land reform, designed to stimulate discussion among the
voluntary agencies on this important topic. He assessed collectivizationor joint
farming of common land as practiced socially radicalized societiesas having proved
unsuccessful, and analyzed land reform in the Bangladesh context. Giving land to the
landless, he stated, had proved impractical, since the landless have no, plough or working
capital; without outside help they are soon 1 to part with the land. A realistic reform
could be "voluntary liquidation of fragmented plots, redistribution of existing
excess land original farmers to keep them from swelling the ranks of the landless,
more equitable system of sharecropping. The difficulty is, however, there is little
available land for distribution, and through inheritance land in the second generation
becomes fragmented into uneconomic plots. Nevertheless, he states, "the main problem
of the rural poor is the power of the rural economic elite, allied with the urban and
political elite, to maintain the existing agrarian structure and even enhance it in their
favor."
When the Caritas Development Institute opened in 1983 TIMM taught Social Analysis and
Bangladesh Analysis in the one-month basic course for Field Extension Workers. His
analysis of post-independence
problems emphasized that the way to change the pattern of exploitation is for villagers
to understand their situation and its cause", organize and together, and enter into
the decision-making process; at the same he insisted, they must develop personal virtues
such as zeal, self-discipline, self-reliance and a willingness to share.
In 1979 TIMM and his colleagues at the First Asian Conference for and Peace in Tokyo
set up Hotline, an all-Asia network to collect on authenticated cases of human rights
infringements. TIMM joined the advisory committee and, since 1980, has supervised the work
of Hotline in Bangladesh; its objective is gathering information, responding to appeals,
investigating violations and publishing the Hotline Newsletter in English and
Bengali. He also helped to establish the Justice and Peace Coordinating Committee for Asia
and Oceaniawith which hotline is now affiliatedand serves as its Training
Coordinator for South Asia.
TIMM's forthright advocacy of social justice does not always comport with the official
stand of the church. "My biggest disappointment," he says, "is the reaction
of the church in general toward the movement toward social justice and human rights."
The church too often, he believes, hides its head in the sand in order not to offend
governments. On the other hand, TIMM does not fully go along with the chorus of critics
against "international capitalism, multinational corporations, consumerism,
etc." heard in some Justice and Peace groups. Nor does he advocate socialist
solutions, despite recognizing class interests as impediments to development and the
"strong Christian ideal imbedded in socialism." In socialism as in capitalism,
he concludes, "the sinfulness of humanity reveals itself prominently." This is
why, even as he advocates active non-violence to achieve basic human rights, TIMM does not
view class struggle per se as inevitable. Rather, both the oppressed and the oppressors
need to achieve a new awareness.
These days TIMM thinks of himself as a social worker. "I've never done typical
missionary activity," he says. "I've never converted a soul, and I've never
tried to." Yet from 1982 to 1986 he was Superior of the Holy Cross Order in
Bangladesh, and he continues to say Mass daily (in Bengali now) and to perform other
priestly functions, just as he has done at every stage of his long and varied career. His
deepest sensitivities remain spiritual. For him, living in Bangladesh has distilled
theology to its essence. Here, he believes, "you are close to reality, to nature, to
simple living, to the reality of the Gospel." Echoing Saint John, he expresses the
Gospel simply: "Little children, love one another."
September 1987
Manila
REPERENCES:
Caritas Bangladesh. Annual Report, 1978. Dhaka .
CORR (Christian Organization for Relief and Rehabilitation). Annual Report,
1972. Dhaka.
CORR-Caritas Reports. Dhaka: CORR. 1975, 1976.
Timm, Richard William. "Chittagong Hill Tracts: I - Historical Review; II - The
Fighting and the Issues; III - Development, Justice ant Peace." Dhaka: Commission for
Justice and Peace of the Catholic Bishops Conference of Bangladesh. 1980. (Mimeograph.)
______. "Discussion on the Sterilization Survey of The Commission for Justice and
Peace." Dhaka:
Commission for Justice and Peace of the Catholic Bishops Conference of Bangladesh.
1986. (Mimeograph.)
______. "Power Relations at Grassroots Level: Implications for Development and
Change." Paper
prepared for Group Discussion. Ramon Magsaysay Award Foundation, Manila. September 4,
1987. (Typewritten.)
______. Power Relations in Rural Development. Hong Kong: Center for Progress of
Peoples, Development in Asia Series. No. 8, 1983.
______. "Women Garment Workers Study." Dhaka: Commission for Justice and
Peace of the Catholic Conference of Bangladesh. 1985.
Saha, Subash Chandra and Richard W. Timm. "A Survey of 950 Sterilized Persans in
Bangladesh." Dhaka: Commission for Justice and Peace of the Catholic Bishops
Conference of Bangladesh. 1985. (Mimeograph.)
Interview with Richard William Timm and interviews with and letters from persons
acquainted with him and his work. Typescript of Timm's personal memoirs.